Many U.S. farmers now plant crops that contain genes from
another species. But from a global perspective such transgenic,
or genetically modified, crops remain relatively uncommon around
the world, according to a
University of Wisconsin-Madison study.
"Many people casually refer to GM or transgenic crop varieties
as being the first step in a 'gene' or biotechnology
'revolution,'" says Fred Buttel, the study's author. "They
herald this development as the beginning of a global revolution
in agriculture."
The numbers, however, do not reveal such a trend, according to
Buttel. The co-director of the Program on Agricultural
Technology Studies, Buttel has studied how farmers have
responded to biotechnology for more than a decade.
"In Wisconsin, the United States and the world as a whole," he
says, "the overall pattern of GM adoption is deep in a handful
of places and crop sectors. For example, there has been
widespread adoption of certain GM crops such as
herbicide-resistant soybeans in the American Midwest and
transgenic cotton in the U.S. South and Southwest. However, GM
adoption is also narrow in that it has bypassed most of
agriculture and is becoming increasingly limited to a handful of
commodities in a handful of countries.
"Both proponents and opponents of GM technology need to
recognize this contradictory nature of GM adoption to understand
the significance of biotechnology in global as well as national
terms."
To evaluate global adoption of the technology, Buttel analyzed
data taken from a web site maintained by the
International Service for the
Acquisition of Agri-Biotech Applications. The data covered
the period from 1996 to 2001.
"These data are widely cited as the most comprehensive public
source of information on the track record of GM crop varieties
across the world," says Buttel, who chairs the Department of
Rural Sociology at the College of Agricultural and Life
Sciences.
"It's clear that the adoption of this technology within the
United States has been extraordinary by world and historical
standards," he says. "Farmers have adopted transgenic varieties
more rapidly than any
agricultural technology in the history of the world. But
globally the adoption of transgenic crops has been slow and
limited."
The major transgenic crops include herbicide-resistant soybeans,
insect-resistant corn, and cotton with one or both of those
traits. Transgenic canola, potato and tomato varieties have also
been available.
From 1996 to 2001, there was an unprecedented expansion in the
acreage of GM soybeans, and to a lesser extent cotton, corn and
canola varieties, in three countries - the United States, Canada
and Argentina. In 2001, 46 percent of the world's soybean
acreage was planted with transgenic varieties, Buttel says.
Those three countries account for more than 95 percent of the
acreage of GM crops. The United States alone now accounts for
almost 70 percent of the world's acreage in GM crops.
Outside of those crops and countries, there are about 5 million
acres of transgenic crops. For comparison, that's about the same
number of acres that Wisconsin farmers planted to corn and
soybeans in 2001.
Because the world's three major food groups are rice, corn and
wheat, there is scarcely any real beginning of a "gene
revolution" in the world's staple crop sectors, according to
Buttel. "Increasingly," he says, "the global diffusion of
transgenic varieties is accounted for by one crop - soybean, -
in one country - the United States - and by the use of one
technology - herbicide resistance."
Globally, soybean has now increased its share of the total GM
acreage from less than 20 percent in 1996 to more than 60
percent in 2001. The next largest GM crop is corn. However, the
share of the GM acreage in corn and canola has declined during
the past 5 years, and GM potatoes and tomatoes never claimed a
significant share of the acreage.
Buttel presented his results to a meeting of the Wisconsin
Agri-service Association in January.
For a copy of the full report, The Adoption and Diffusion of GM
Crop Varieties: The 'Gene Revolution' in Global Perspective,
1996 -2001, contact Nancy Carlisle at (608) 265-2908,
nlcarlis@facstaff.wisc.edu.
The publication is also available at
http://www.wisc.edu/pats/pubsp.htm the site for the
Program's series of staff papers.
Writer: George Gallepp (608) 262-3636
Agricultural and Consumer Press Service College of
Agricultural and Life Sciences
University of Wisconsin-Madison
Research Division
440 Henry Mall
Madison WI 53706
(608) 262-1461