St. Louis, Missouri
October 1, 2003
A U.S. District Court today denied efforts to
certify an antitrust class-action suit levied against
Monsanto (NYSE: MON) and
other companies over biotechnology seed products sold to
American farmers. On Sept. 26, the same court dismissed all
"tort claims" asserted in the same suit that attacked the
introduction of biotechnology. Combined with today's decision,
the District Court has now eliminated both theories advanced in
the plaintiffs' class-action lawsuit originally initiated in
1999.
In
describing the plaintiffs' attempt to bring the class-action
antitrust suit, the Court's decision described the plaintiffs'
premise as based on a "house-of-cards."
"This ruling
is a clear victory for Monsanto and for biotechnology," said
Charles Burson, general counsel for Monsanto. "The plaintiffs'
allegations were a vestige of the mistaken attacks that have
made against biotechnology for years. The allegations now have
been shown not to be representative of fact or the experience of
farmers."
In the
original lawsuit filed in 1999, the plaintiffs made two
allegations -- that biotechnology products were insufficiently
tested and introduced to the market, and Monsanto and other seed
companies conspired to fix price premiums for biotechnology
varieties at unreasonably high levels.
Today's
ruling disposes of all purported class-action antitrust claims
against Monsanto, Syngenta, Bayer and DuPont. Coupled with the
Sept. 26 ruling that dismissed all tort claims in the original
suit that alleged biotechnology products were inappropriately
introduced, all of the claims made by the plaintiffs have been
resolved in Monsanto's favor.
Monsanto
Company is a leading global provider of technology-based
solutions and agricultural products that improve farm
productivity and food quality. |