2. The phytosanitary regulations
The phytosanitary regulations are governed, at
international level, by the International Plant Protection
Convention, IPPC, administered by FAO, and in harmony with
the Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and
Phytosanitary measures (SPS) of the WTO. According to
these convention and agreement, it is recognized that
countries may exercise the sovereign right to utilize
phytosanitary measures to regulate the entry of plants and
plant products capable of harbouring plant pests. For the
sake of transparency, countries have to publish their
restrictions and requirements. In addition, they also have
to notify changes and, except in urgent circumstances,
countries have to allow a reasonable interval between the
publication of a regulation and its entry into force to
allow exporting countries to adapt their products and
methods of production. Finally, as conditions change and
as new facts become available, phytosanitary measures have
to be modified possibly by removal of those found to be
unnecessary.
If all these principles are indisputable, unfortunately
their implementation is often questionable. Countries often do
not publish lists of quarantine pests and from time to time
add new pests without notice, blocking shipment at the port of
entry; they change their rules without new technical
justification and without allowing enough time to fulfil the
new requirements; finally they are also very reluctant to
change their rules when new facts indicate for instance that
maintaining a pest on a quarantine list is no longer
justified.
In order to limit these trade barriers as much as possible,
ISF is working at several levels:
- At technical levels, by developing testing methods for
seed-borne diseases and Pest Risk Analysis for possible
non-justified quarantine pests. This is done by the ISHIs.
- At national level, ISF has established a procedure to
react quickly in case a new problem arises in a country.
This procedure is implemented with the participation of
the national seed association of that country.
- At international level, in being active at the IPPC
level, where we have an observer status.
However, despite these actions and the international
treaties, I am afraid that the phytosanitary issues will
remain worrying in the future and we have had several
examples recently in several countries.
The new development against exotic species is also to
be linked to these phytosanitary issues. New regulations,
often dictated by dogmatic conservation biologists may
have a very detrimental effect on the seed industry and
the international seed trade.